Community Notes on X: what they are and how a note gets shown

Community Notes are short additions to posts on X. Volunteer contributors write them, other contributors rate them, and a note only becomes visible if people with differing views have found it helpful. This is an important feature, so it will be covered in more detail in this lesson.

Term Plain meaning
Community Note Context added below a post by volunteer contributors
Contributor A user who has joined the program to rate and, later, write notes
Needs More Ratings The starting status of every new note; only contributors see it
Helpful The status a note needs before regular users can see it
Birdwatch The program’s original name, used from January 2021 to November 2022

What is a Community Note?

A Community Note is a crowd-written explanation attached to a post that adds facts or context readers might be missing.

Community Notes provide context to a post from other users. For example, they could highlight that a photo is old, that statistics in a quote are from a different country or that important information is missing from a claim about a product. Usually, a source is provided so that people can verify the claim for themselves. The post stays up, and the note appears below it with a label saying readers added context.

Where did Community Notes come from?

The feature started as Birdwatch on January 23, 2021, and was renamed Community Notes in November 2022.

Birdwatch was tested with a limited number of people in the USA. Initially, notes were displayed on a separate website, but during 2022 they started to appear below posts for all users in the USA. In late 2022, following a change in ownership, the project was renamed. In December 2022, the notes began rolling out to users in other countries.

Date What happened
January 23, 2021 Birdwatch launches as a pilot
2022 Helpful notes start showing to all US users
November 2022 Birdwatch is renamed Community Notes
December 2022 Global rollout begins

Who writes Community Notes?

Notes are written and rated by enrolled contributors, not by X staff.

Anyone can apply to be a contributor. Basic requirements include not having broken any rules recently, having a confirmed phone number and having had an account for a period of time. A company representative told CBS News in 2023 that users must have had an account for at least 6 months. However, applicants are accepted in batches, so meeting the requirements does not guarantee that someone will become a contributor right away.

New contributors cannot add notes at first. They can only rate notes added by others. Once their ratings have matched closely enough with how notes end up being assessed, they can start writing notes. To keep that ability, most of the notes they write must be rated helpful over time.

How does a note get shown to everyone?

A note is shown only after it collects enough helpful ratings from contributors who have disagreed with each other in the past.

Notes will initially be in a ‘Needs More Ratings’ stage. This means that only contributors can see them. Contributors can rate them as helpful, somewhat helpful or not helpful. However, this isn’t simply done by counting the helpful ratings. Instead, the system takes into account the history of the contributors giving ratings. If people who usually rate things differently have given helpful ratings, this indicates a good quality note. This is often referred to as a bridging method, as the note must bridge views.

If 40 people with similar views give helpful ratings, the note may still be hidden. However, if fewer people have given ratings overall, but people with differing views have given helpful ratings, there is a much greater chance that the note will be shown. The aim of this system is that notes which a wide range of people would accept are the ones shown. The code used to calculate ratings can be viewed on GitHub.

Why do some notes never appear?

Most notes stay hidden because they never reach agreement across different groups of raters.

Sometimes a note contains opinion presented as fact, and raters mark it down. Some notes may be correct but added too late to make a difference to the spread of the post. Finally, many notes simply do not get the right mix of ratings. This is a key compromise within this system. By requiring agreement between differing views, we can be more confident that public notes are reliable. However, a large number of sensible notes will remain in the ‘Needs More Ratings’ stage.

How should you read a note under a post?

Read the note, then open its source link before you repost or reply.

Although a note appearing on a post is a strong indicator, it isn’t a court ruling. Depending on the note, it may correct the original statement, or just add information (such as a date). Open the link to the source of the note. Usually this will be a news article, an official page or the original document. If you liked, replied to or reposted the post, you may be notified once a note appears. This means you can decide whether to continue sharing the post.

What if a note appears on your own post?

Your post stays up, but you should check the note and correct yourself if it is right.

The note won’t remove your post. If the note is correct, the best way to fix the mistake is to reply or create a new post that corrects it. Deleting the post and re-posting won’t help, since contributors can add a note to the new post too. If you believe that the note is incorrect, contributors can rate it, and as more ratings come in, the status of a note can change.

Related from the archive: Watch Out For Twitter Risks

FAQ

Does X write or edit Community Notes?

No. Notes are written and rated by enrolled contributors. X runs the program and publishes the scoring code, but the text of a note comes from contributors.

Can I see notes that are not public yet?

Only if you are a contributor. Notes in the Needs More Ratings status are shown to contributors so they can rate them, and regular users do not see them.

Can I ask for a note on a post?

Yes. X added a way to request a note. If a post gets enough requests, contributors with a strong writing record are alerted so they can look at it.

Was Birdwatch a different feature?

No. Birdwatch was the original name of the same program. It was renamed Community Notes in November 2022.

Sources


Posted

in

by